• Login
    • Join
  • FOLLOW:
  • Subscribe Free
    • Magazine
    • eNewsletter
    Checkout
    • Magazine
    • News
    • Printed Electronics
    • Raw Materials
    • Equipment
    • Services
    • Suppliers Guide
    • Resources
    • More
  • Magazine
  • News
  • Printed Electronics
  • Raw Materials
  • Equipment
  • Services
  • Suppliers Guide
  • Resources
  • Current & Past Issues
    Features
    Editorials
    Digital Edition
    Subscribe Now
    Advertise Now
    eNewsletter Archive
    Our Team
    Editorial Guidelines
    Breaking News
    Experts Opinion
    Financial News
    Manufacturers News
    Mergers and Acquisitions
    Online Exclusives
    Personnel
    Product Releases
    Suppliers News
    Live From Shows
    Displays and Lighting
    Photovoltaics
    Printed Batteries
    Printed Circuit Boards/Membrane Switches/In Mold Electronics
    Flexible and Printed Electronics
    RFID and NFC
    Sensors and Wearables
    Smart Cards and Packaging
    Touch Screens
    Adhesives, Barriers and Encapsulants
    Chemicals, Metals and Powders
    Conductive Inks and Coatings
    Electronic Materials
    Film, Paper, Glass and Substrates
    Graphene, Perovskites and Carbon Nanotubes
    Nanomaterials
    Printed Electronic Components
    Research Reports
    Semiconductors and Quantum Dots
    Energy Curing Equipment
    Lab and Testing Equipment
    Manufacturing Equipment
    Printing Equipment
    3D Printing
    Contract Manufacturing Services
    Product Design and Testing
    Research and Consulting
    Research Institutions
    Research Reports
    Universities
    Equipment
    All Companies
    Materials
    Categories
    Converting
    Printed Electronics Systems
    Associations
    Research and Services
    Used Machinery
    Add New Company
    Industry Events
    Live from show events
    Podcasts
    Videos
    Blogs
    Slideshows
    Infographics
    Webinars
    Whitepapers
    Equipment and Services
    Glossary
    • Magazine
      • Current & Past Issues
      • Features
      • Editorial
      • Columns
      • Digital Edition
      • eNewsletter Archive
      • Editorial Guidelines
      • Subscribe Now
      • Advertise Now
    • Breaking News
    • Suppliers Guide
      • Add Your Company
      • Suppliers Guide
    • Printed Electronics
      • Photovoltaics
      • Printed Batteries
      • Printed Circuit Boards/Membrane Switches/In Mold Electronics
      • Flexible and Printed Electronics
      • RFID and NFC
      • Sensors and Wearables
      • Smart Cards and Packaging
      • Touch Screens
    • Raw Materials
      • Adhesives, Barriers and Encapsulants
      • Chemicals, Metals and Powders
      • Conductive Inks and Coatings
      • Electronic Materials
      • Film, Paper, Glass and Substrates
      • Graphene, Perovskites and Carbon Nanotubes
      • Nanomaterials
      • Semiconductors and Quantum Dots
    • Equipment
      • Energy Curing Equipment
      • Lab and Testing Equipment
      • Manufacturing Equipment
      • Printing Equipment
      • 3D Printing
    • Services
      • Contract Manufacturing Services
      • Product Design and Testing
      • Research and Consulting
      • Research Institutions
      • Research Reports
      • Universities
    • Online Exclusives
    • Slideshows
    • Blog
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Infographics
    • Events
      • Industry Events
      • Live from show events
      • Webinars
    • About Us
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
      • Advertise With Us
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Use
    Breaking News

    NREL: Improvements in PV Performance Measurement

    For the past four years, NREL has prioritized improvements to its methods for measuring PV module efficiency.

    NREL: Improvements in PV Performance Measurement
    Allen Anderberg (left), Steve Rummel, and Dean Levi of NREL's Cell and Module Performance group measure the power output of a PV module on NREL's solar simulator. Photo by Dennis Schroeder, NREL
    Related CONTENT
    • NREL Names Achilles Karagiozis as Buildings, Thermal Sciences Center Director
    • NREL Seeks Participants for 2019 Executive Energy Leadership Program
    • NREL Research Proves Switchable Window Works
    • NREL’s New Supercomputer, Eagle, Takes Flight
    • NREL: 'Great Potential' for Floating PV Systems
    02.26.19

    The solar industry wants certainty, not approximations because a lot rides on the separation of exact from merely close. Uncertainty, or margin of error, can cost a solar module manufacturer millions of dollars.

    "This is over a $30 billion industry now," said Keith Emery, a consultant to the U.S. Department of Energy's (DOE's) National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) and, before he retired in 2016, the point person for the laboratory's work to measure the efficiency of photovoltaic (PV) technology. "That $30 billion industry is weighted in units of watts, so a 1% uncertainty in a $30 billion industry is a big deal."

    For the past four years, NREL has prioritized improvements to its methods for measuring PV module efficiency. Vital to that effort was significantly reducing uncertainties. Now NREL stands out globally as the laboratory with the lowest uncertainty rate when it comes to measuring the power of a PV module, at plus or minus 1.1%.

    "Manufacturers need some kind of yardstick at the end of their production line because they're cranking out thousands of modules a day," said Dean Levi, Emery's successor and manager of the Cell and Module Performance group in the National Center for Photovoltaics at NREL.

    Manufacturers price PV modules based on watts generated and typically provide a power tolerance of -0% to +3%. Take a 300-watt solar module—which sells for 30 cents per watt on the global wholesale market. That margin of error for this module equates to 9 watts.

    "Because of the way PV modules are rated for power, there's a pretty good chance they're selling you a 309-watt module for the price of a 300-watt module – and they don't like that," Levi said. "Manufacturers have been pushing for a long time for labs like ours to reduce our uncertainties because then they don't have to sell a 309-watt module for the price of 300 watts. If their uncertainty is plus or minus 1%, they can instead sell that 309-watt module as a 306-watt module, so they've made that much more money." 


    NREL Technician Larry Ottoson sets up to measure primary reference cells at NREL’s Outdoor Test Facility. Photo by Dennis Schroeder, NREL
     

    Although that only amounts to $1.80 more per module, large PV manufacturers produce more than 30 million 300-watt modules per year, so this small reduction in uncertainty can result in a $50 million improvement in annual revenues.

    Including NREL, four laboratories dominate in providing the most exact measurements of PV cells and modules. The others are in Germany, Italy, and Japan. Each country relies on a certifying agency to ensure exacting standards are met. In the United States, the American Association for Laboratory Accreditation (A2LA) serves that function. A2LA has certified NREL's uncertainties for primary reference cells (0.4%), secondary reference cells (0.6%), and the previously mentioned reference modules (1.1%).

    "With each of these, we became the lowest uncertainty in the world when we attained those accreditations," Levi said. "We're lower than any of the other laboratories." The uncertainty for reference modules at the other labs ranges from 1.3–1.6%.

    Modules, which typically are made up of either 60 or 72 connected solar cells, undergo rigorous testing before reaching the market. Private test laboratories shoot ice balls at them to make sure they're hail-resistant, expose them to repeated wide swings in temperature and humidity, mechanically stress them, and measure their energy output versus temperature and irradiance.

    But handling what's called a "golden module" requires expertise only found at NREL.


    Dean Levi, manager of NREL’s Cell and Module Performance group, reviews measurements of a PV module. Photo by Dennis Schroeder, NREL

    To ensure proper calibration, manufacturers usually send at least two modules of the same model type to NREL's South Table Mountain Campus in Golden, Colorado. There, the output performance of each is measured and the laboratory certifies that the module produces, for example, 302 watts, plus or minus 1.1%. 

    Back at the factory, the modules are used to check that output against the company's solar simulator, which is essentially a large table that illuminates the module with light approximating sunlight.


    "One of the biggest uncertainties in measuring power output is how accurately can you measure the light output of your simulator," Levi said. "With this golden module, the manufacturer can set the light output of their simulator very accurately. Then they put that module in a safe place and they get out another module, just like the first one. They measure that module on the simulator and that's their ‘silver module.' That one they'll use every morning, or maybe several times a day, to set the intensity of their simulator."
    "The simulator sits at the end of the production line," Levi continued." Every module that comes off the production line gets tested, and its power output gets assigned, based on that simulator—which is ultimately traceable back to our measurement of their module."


    NREL calibrated over 800 modules for internal and external customers in Fiscal Year (FY) 2018.
    NREL has served as a resource for the industry since 1980 when the laboratory (then known as the Solar Energy Research Institute) took over measuring solar technology from NASA. Emery, who led that program for 37 years, said the margin of error for modules at that time was 10%.


    In 2015, when the uncertainty rate hovered around 3%, DOE (which provides most of the funding for NREL's work), set a goal for the laboratory to reduce its uncertainty level to below 2% by the end of FY 2018. Emery said the direction given to NREL was clear. "We want you to be as accurate as possible.
     

    "We took that seriously and devoted significant labor resources to it," Emery added.

    Emery and Levi give credit to Carl Osterwald (an NREL electrical engineer) and Larry Ottoson (a technician at the laboratory's Outdoor Test Facility) for enabling NREL to reduce the margin of error beyond the DOE goal. The duo worked to eliminate anything that was causing errors in the calibrations.


    To calibrate modules, NREL relies on three different test beds: a continuous solar simulator, a pulsed solar simulator, and one outdoors using natural sunlight. Ottoson dedicated himself to improving the equipment—eliminating light leaks, for example, that could skew the results.


    "Not any one of our systems by itself could get better than 2%," Osterwald said. "So, we had to use a combination method. It was a combination of a whole bunch of things. We completely changed the calibration procedure for PV modules."


    One change considered the fact that light from a simulator isn't uniform, something that can dominate the uncertainty. In the new procedure, the current produced by a module is first calibrated outdoors, which provides a very uniform light source. Then, that carefully calibrated module can be used as its own reference module for the other tests. After the current is measured outdoors, the module is put into a simulator and the light level is set correctly.


    NREL coined the term "module self-reference," or MSR, to refer to how a test module serves as its own reference. Instead of purchasing an expensive new simulator to calibrate modules, NREL's MSR takes advantage of the strengths of the three test beds.
    "There's only one laboratory that does our procedure, and t

    hat's us," Osterwald said. "Other laboratories have their own way of doing things. They're different. We've just improved what we were doing before."
    Around 2008, when PV modules were selling for $5 a watt, a flood of startup companies was sending their modules to NREL for measurement. "We were probably doing a volume five times what we do now," Levi said.


    With prices now around 30 cents a watt, the financial underpinning of startups has collapsed and the demand for measurements has lessened. But providing as exact a measurement as possible remains important—especially for the banking sector.


    "A lot of the PV power we get is from huge utility-scale power plants they build out in the desert or out in the plains," Levi said. "Most of those are financed by banks, and banks don't like risk. If a bank perceives more risk in a project, they're going to charge a higher interest rate. And that interest rate directly impacts the cost of the power that the project produces.


    "If the banks have higher confidence in the energy output, then they're going to charge a lower interest rate," Levi continued. "That's one of the major factors that DOE has identified as a pathway to reduce the cost of solar energy: To reduce the perceived risk by the investors."

    Related Searches
    • photovoltaic
    • solar
    • photovoltaics
    • NREL
    Suggested For You
    NREL Names Achilles Karagiozis as Buildings, Thermal Sciences Center Director NREL Names Achilles Karagiozis as Buildings, Thermal Sciences Center Director
    NREL Seeks Participants for 2019 Executive Energy Leadership Program NREL Seeks Participants for 2019 Executive Energy Leadership Program
    NREL Research Proves Switchable Window Works NREL Research Proves Switchable Window Works
    NREL’s New Supercomputer, Eagle, Takes Flight NREL’s New Supercomputer, Eagle, Takes Flight
    NREL: NREL: 'Great Potential' for Floating PV Systems
    Better Explanation of Coalescence-Related Defects Receives Journal Spotlight Better Explanation of Coalescence-Related Defects Receives Journal Spotlight
    Oxford PV Perovskite Solar Cell Achieves 28% Efficiency Oxford PV Perovskite Solar Cell Achieves 28% Efficiency
    Modeling, Monitoring, Microgrids: ORNL Provides Help as Puerto Rico Rebuilds Modeling, Monitoring, Microgrids: ORNL Provides Help as Puerto Rico Rebuilds
    Dan Friedman Named APS Fellow for Work on High-Efficiency Photovoltaics Dan Friedman Named APS Fellow for Work on High-Efficiency Photovoltaics
    NREL Inks a Future for Perovskites NREL Inks a Future for Perovskites
    NREL Interns Energize the Laboratory NREL Interns Energize the Laboratory
    NREL’s Eric Payne Wins Technology Transfer Professional of the Year Award NREL’s Eric Payne Wins Technology Transfer Professional of the Year Award

    Related Breaking News

    • Breaking News | Conductive Inks and Coatings | Flexible and Printed Electronics
      PRINTING United Alliance Announces TAGA Presents Virtual Event

      PRINTING United Alliance Announces TAGA Presents Virtual Event

      Registration is free and now open for the two-day session.
      Anthony Locicero, Editor 01.26.21

    • Breaking News | Research Institutions | Semiconductors and Quantum Dots
      ITRI, DuPont Jointly Inaugurate Semiconductor Materials Lab

      ITRI, DuPont Jointly Inaugurate Semiconductor Materials Lab

      DuPont, in collaboration with ITRI, will conduct semiconductor material research, development and enhancement, and accelerate pilot testing.
      Anthony Locicero, Associate editor 01.26.21

    • Breaking News | Personnel | RFID and NFC
      Identiv Appoints Leigh Dow as VP of Marketing

      Identiv Appoints Leigh Dow as VP of Marketing

      Newly created role is part of the company’s ongoing transformation to become the leading provider of security and identity solutions.
      Anthony Locicero 01.26.21


    • Breaking News | Flexible and Printed Electronics | Research Institutions
      Imec Technology Taking Off to Space

      Imec Technology Taking Off to Space

      Imec will validate three of its technologies in a spaceflight environment. Being compact and sophisticated makes these systems attractive for implementation.
      Anthony Locicero, Associate editor 01.26.21

    • Breaking News | Displays and Lighting
      Osram in Top 25 of World’s 100 Most Sustainable Companies

      Osram in Top 25 of World’s 100 Most Sustainable Companies

      Out of approximately 7,400 worldwide companies, Osram ranks 23rd.
      Anthony Locicero, Associate editor 01.26.21

    • Breaking News | Graphene, Perovskites and Carbon Nanotubes | Research Institutions
      Graphene Flagship Study Predicts Increased Market Penetration by 2025

      Graphene Flagship Study Predicts Increased Market Penetration by 2025

      Most immediate applications of graphene, such as composites, inks and coatings are already commercially available.
      Anthony Locicero, Associate editor 01.25.21


    • Breaking News | RFID and NFC
      STMicroelectronics Powers NFC Applications with Message Content, Anti-Tamper in New Type-5 Tags

      STMicroelectronics Powers NFC Applications with Message Content, Anti-Tamper in New Type-5 Tags

      Tags deliver advantages such as extended communication range with superior reliability.
      Anthony Locicero, Associate editor 01.25.21

    • Breaking News | Suppliers News
      DuPont, Corteva, Chemours Announce Resolution of Legacy PFAS Claims

      DuPont, Corteva, Chemours Announce Resolution of Legacy PFAS Claims

      Companies also settle remaining Ohio multi-district PFOA litigation.
      Anthony Locicero, Associate editor 01.25.21

    • Breaking News | Displays and Lighting

      UDC Subsidiary Adesis' Website Wins 2020 MarCom Platinum Award

      “Our website is one of the primary thresholds to our brand," said Andrew Cottone, president of Adesis, Inc.
      Anthony Locicero, Associate editor 01.25.21


    • Breaking News | Semiconductors and Quantum Dots
      Ambiq Wins IoT Semiconductor Company of the Year Award

      Ambiq Wins IoT Semiconductor Company of the Year Award

      Ambiq believes that innovation is essential to the advancement of human society.
      Anthony Locicero, Associate editor 01.22.21

    • Breaking News | Displays and Lighting | Flexible and Printed Electronics | Personnel | Suppliers News
      Ynvisible Names Michael Robinson CEO, Jani-Mikael Kuusisto SVP Ventures

      Ynvisible Names Michael Robinson CEO, Jani-Mikael Kuusisto SVP Ventures

      Ynvisible is focusing on speed to market for customer products and sustainable financial growth.
      David Savastano, Editor 01.22.21

    • Breaking News | Photovoltaics | Research Institutions
      IHSMarkit Reports Top Clean-Tech Trends for 2021

      IHSMarkit Reports Top Clean-Tech Trends for 2021

      Solar surges by 30%, 10 GW milestone for offshore wind among highlights.
      David Savastano, Editor 01.22.21


    • Breaking News | RFID and NFC
      Roadsimple Modernizes Warehouse Ops with Zebra Technologies

      Roadsimple Modernizes Warehouse Ops with Zebra Technologies

      Roadsimple 'transformed our warehouse from a manual-based operation using pen and paper to a truly modernized one,' said Hao Fang, IT director.
      Printed Electronics Now staff 01.22.21

    • Breaking News | Sensors and Wearables
      Emerson Receives 2021 IoT Breakthrough Award for Analytics Platform of the Year

      Emerson Receives 2021 IoT Breakthrough Award for Analytics Platform of the Year

      Real-time data and analytics are key drivers for optimizing operational performance, asset health and plant safety.
      Printed Electronics Now Staff 01.21.21

    • Breaking News | Graphene, Perovskites and Carbon Nanotubes | Research Institutions
      Graphene Flagship Launches Redesigned Website

      Graphene Flagship Launches Redesigned Website

      Site features completely redesigned aesthetic, with emphasis on easy-to-access informative content presented in a simple, clean and visually appealing way.
      Printed Electronics Now staff 01.20.21

    Trending
    • Osram In Top 25 Of World’s 100 Most Sustainable Companies
    • DuPont, Corteva, Chemours Announce Resolution Of Legacy PFAS Claims
    • Graphene Flagship Study Predicts Increased Market Penetration By 2025
    • Phiaro Corporation Incorporates TactoTek IMSE Smart Surfaces Into Customer Projects
    • TNO At Holst Centre Develops Cuddle Vest
    Breaking News
    • PRINTING United Alliance Announces TAGA Presents Virtual Event
    • ITRI, DuPont Jointly Inaugurate Semiconductor Materials Lab
    • Identiv Appoints Leigh Dow as VP of Marketing
    • Imec Technology Taking Off to Space
    • Osram in Top 25 of World’s 100 Most Sustainable Companies
    View Breaking News >
    CURRENT ISSUE

    Fall 2020

    • Flexible Electronics Is Proving to Be Ideal for Healthcare
    • COVID-19 and the Printed Electronics Industry
    • Smart Packaging Looks to Move Forward
    • Electronic & Conductive Ink Conference Showcases Future of Ink Technology
    • Printed Electronics Now’s International Suppliers’ Directory
    • View More >

    Cookies help us to provide you with an excellent service. By using our website, you declare yourself in agreement with our use of cookies.
    You can obtain detailed information about the use of cookies on our website by clicking on "More information”.

    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms And Conditions
    • Contact Us

    follow us

    Subscribe
    Nutraceuticals World

    Latest Breaking News From Nutraceuticals World

    Omega-3s Evidenced to Reduce Low-Grade Inflammation in Elderly Men
    MIND and Mediterranean Diets Linked to Later Onset of Parkinson’s Disease
    Kerry Launches Web-Based Tool for Plant-Based Formulation Challenges
    Coatings World

    Latest Breaking News From Coatings World

    Keyland Polymer UV Powder, LLC Launches UVMax Defender
    Scott McLaughlin to Race in PPG Colors During Rookie INDYCAR Season
    Vink Chemicals Offers parmetol PSG
    Medical Product Outsourcing

    Latest Breaking News From Medical Product Outsourcing

    Butterfly Network Appoints New Leader
    BD Names Chairman of Board
    Interplex Acquires OCP Group
    Contract Pharma

    Latest Breaking News From Contract Pharma

    Adare Pharma Solutions Opens New Small-Scale Lab
    Stevanato Group Launches After-sales Service Offering
    X-Chem Acquires IntelliSyn and AviSyn
    Beauty Packaging

    Latest Breaking News From Beauty Packaging

    The Estée Lauder Companies Announces Game-Changing Sustainability Goals for Travel Retail
    Aura Introduces Customizable Hair Care
    Corpack Creates Custom Packaging for Marlies Möller Hair Care Line
    Happi

    Latest Breaking News From Happi

    Nice-Pak Receives EPA Approval for Disinfectant Wipes
    FDA Takes Major Action on Hand Sanitizers from Mexico
    Symrise Shares 2020 Sales Figures
    Ink World

    Latest Breaking News From Ink World

    Epson Partner Creates Label Applicators for Pharmaceutical Products
    Smurfit Kappa Sets New Sustainability Targets with Better Planet 2050
    Paragon Expands Direct Mail Capabilities with Ricoh Pro VC70000
    Label & Narrow Web

    Latest Breaking News From Label & Narrow Web

    Great Lakes Label debuts new website
    Epson partner creates label applicators for pharmaceutical products
    ACTEGA removes chemicals from laminating adhesives
    Nonwovens Industry

    Latest Breaking News From Nonwovens Industry

    American Made Production Equipment for Mask Manufacturers
    Kimberly-Clark Releases Q4, Full Year Results
    Freudenberg to Establish Apparel Interlining Competence Centers
    Orthopedic Design & Technology

    Latest Breaking News From Orthopedic Design & Technology

    Spinal Elements' Lucent XP-Curved Expandable TLIF Gains FDA Nod
    FDA OKs OrthoSpin's 2nd Gen Robotic, Digital External Fixation System
    Nextremity Solutions Enters Supply Agreement with Fort Wayne Metals
    Printed Electronics Now

    Latest Breaking News From Printed Electronics Now

    North American Semiconductor Equipment Industry Posts December 2020 Billings
    First Solar Signs Definitive Agreement to Sell US Development Platform to Leeward
    PRINTING United Alliance Announces TAGA Presents Virtual Event

    Copyright © 2021 Rodman Media. All rights reserved. Use of this constitutes acceptance of our privacy policy The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Rodman Media.

    AD BLOCKER DETECTED

    Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
    Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.


    FREE SUBSCRIPTION Already a subscriber? Login